What is the difference between pyrite and pyrrhotite
1 Answer
Leave an answer
You must login to add an answer.
Sign up to join our community!
Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
You must login to add an answer.
Pyrite and pyrrhotite are both iron sulfide minerals, but they differ significantly in their physical and chemical properties. Below is a detailed comparison between the two: ### 1. **Chemical Composition**: - **Pyrite (FeS₂)**: Pyrite consists of iron (Fe) and sulfur (S) in a fixed ratio of 1:2. ItRead more
Pyrite and pyrrhotite are both iron sulfide minerals, but they differ significantly in their physical and chemical properties. Below is a detailed comparison between the two:
### 1. **Chemical Composition**:
– **Pyrite (FeS₂)**: Pyrite consists of iron (Fe) and sulfur (S) in a fixed ratio of 1:2. It has a highly ordered crystal structure, where each iron atom is bonded to two sulfur atoms.
– **Pyrrhotite (Fe₁₋ₓS)**: Pyrrhotite has a variable composition, with iron deficiency (ₓ) in its structure. Its chemical formula is often written as Fe₁₋ₓS, meaning it has less iron compared to pyrite. This variation gives pyrrhotite different magnetic and physical properties.
### 2. **Crystal Structure**:
– **Pyrite**: Pyrite forms in the **isometric crystal system**, typically exhibiting cubic or octahedral crystals. This crystal symmetry contributes to its nickname “fool’s gold” due to its shiny, metallic luster and well-defined shape.
– **Pyrrhotite**: Pyrrhotite forms in the **monoclinic or hexagonal crystal system** and typically appears in more massive or granular forms, rather than the well-defined cubic structures seen in pyrite.
### 3. **Color and Appearance**:
– **Pyrite**: Pyrite is a pale, brassy-yellow color with a metallic luster, often resembling gold. It is hard and brittle.
– **Pyrrhotite**: Pyrrhotite tends to be darker, ranging from bronze to brownish-black, with a less shiny, more matte metallic luster. It can also appear tarnished or have a reddish hue due to oxidation.
### 4. **Hardness**:
– **Pyrite**: Pyrite has a Mohs hardness of **6 to 6.5**, making it harder than pyrrhotite.
– **Pyrrhotite**: Pyrrhotite is softer, with a Mohs hardness of **3.5 to 4.5**, which means it can be scratched more easily than pyrite.
5. Magnetic Properties:
Pyrite: Pyrite is non-magnetic.
Pyrrhotite: Pyrrhotite is weakly to strongly magnetic due to the iron deficiency in its structure. The more iron-deficient the mineral is, the stronger its magnetic properties. This is a key distinguishing feature between the two minerals.
6. Occurrence and Associations:
Pyrite: Pyrite is very common and found in various geological environments, from sedimentary deposits to hydrothermal veins. It is often associated with quartz and other sulfide minerals.
Pyrrhotite: Pyrrhotite is less common than pyrite and is typically found in mafic igneous rocks and high-temperature ore deposits. It is often associated with nickel, platinum, and copper deposits.
7. Tarnish and Weathering:
Pyrite: Pyrite is more stable in surface conditions but can oxidize over time, forming a yellowish tarnish. In humid conditions, it can form sulfuric acid, leading to acid mine drainage.
Pyrrhotite: Pyrrhotite is less stable and oxidizes more easily, often developing a reddish-brown tarnish. This makes it more prone to weathering in the presence of air and water.
8. Economic Importance:
See lessPyrite: Pyrite is primarily mined for sulfur and sulfuric acid production, although it has little direct economic value for gold despite its appearance.
Pyrrhotite: Pyrrhotite is important in the mining of **nickel** and other metals, often found in sulfide-rich ore bodies. Its magnetic properties make it useful for identifying ore deposits in geophysical surveys.